Risk warning: CFDs are leveraged and most retail accounts lose money.
FX Cashback Site is an introducing broker (IB). XM, Exness and Vantage pay us commission when you trade through our partner links, and part of it is paid back to you as cashback by your broker.
We earn from all three brokers.
Rate being confirmed
XM fits traders on standard accounts who want XM's own promotions alongside a rebate. Vantage fits RAW ECN traders and anyone who wants to keep an existing account, because Vantage accounts can move to a new partner with a form. Our rebate per lot for both is below, or you can compare all three brokers.
Rebate Side by Side
Cashback is a fixed dollar amount per lot on every XM and Vantage account, which makes this the easiest of our comparisons to read. A higher number in the table means more cashback on the same trade. The table opens with the partner code rule, because for existing clients that rule often decides the choice before the rate does.
| Broker | Partner code rule | Account types | Gold, standard account | EUR/USD, standard account | EUR/USD, raw account |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vantage cashbackStandard STP, RAW ECN | Existing Vantage clients can change affiliate from their profile with the Transfer IB/CPA/Sales form. | Standard STP, RAW ECN, PRO ECN | Rate being confirmed | Rate being confirmed | Rate being confirmed |
| XM cashbackStandard, Zero | XM adds a partner code only when an account is created. Open a new account under your current XM profile with our partner code, then move your funds with an internal transfer. | Standard, Ultra Low, Zero | Rate being confirmed | Rate being confirmed | Rate being confirmed |
Account names differ, so compare like with like. XM offers Standard, Ultra Low and Zero. Vantage offers Standard STP, RAW ECN and PRO ECN. Put XM Standard next to Vantage Standard STP, and XM Zero next to Vantage RAW ECN.
Gold sits before EUR/USD in this table on purpose. Gold carries a wider spread at both brokers, so the gold column is where the rebate makes the biggest difference to what you pay.
Trade both gold and currencies? Look at the column for the instrument where most of your lots go. Someone who trades 80 gold lots and 20 EUR/USD lots a month should judge mostly on the gold figure, even if the other broker pays more on EUR/USD.
Costs After Cashback
This example puts gold next to EUR/USD, because many XM and Vantage traders mix the two. It runs 20, 100 and 200 lots a month through XM Standard against Vantage Standard STP on gold, and XM Zero against Vantage RAW ECN on EUR/USD.
Rate being confirmed
Standard accounts put the whole cost in the spread. Raw accounts split it into a tight spread plus commission. XM Zero pairs raw spreads with a commission per lot. Source: Investing in the Web, as of . Vantage Standard STP has no commission, while RAW ECN charges one per side. Source: Fueler, as of .
If gold is most of your volume, the gold rows matter more than the EUR/USD rows, and the 200 lot column shows how fast a small per lot gap grows. To test your own mix of instruments, run your own numbers.
Swap is not in these numbers. If you keep gold positions open overnight, the swap charge can outweigh the spread over a week or two, so add it to your own sums before you pick an account on cost alone.
Promotions and Bonuses vs Rebates
Some traders choose XM for its promotions, and Vantage runs promotions too. Our rebate is a separate payment that comes from the IB commission. What you need to know is whether a promotion lets you keep both.
| Promotion | What XM pays | Stacks with our rebate | As of |
|---|---|---|---|
| XM Unlimited Cashback | Being confirmed | Being confirmed | Being confirmed |
Read the stacking line under each promotion. XM runs its own Unlimited Cashback promotion. It is a separate XM offer under XM terms, apart from the rebate on our code. Source: InvestingLive, as of .
Two rules of thumb. A bonus that adds credit to your account is not cash, and lots traded on credit may not earn a full rebate. At XM, the bonus margin portion of a trade earns no rebate. Source: TradingFinder, as of . And if you trade enough lots for the rebate to add up, no one off bonus is worth leaving our partner code for.
Worth asking either broker before you sign up for a promotion: does a partner code on the account change the offer, do bonus lots count for the rebate, and is there a minimum trading volume before the bonus can be withdrawn?
Existing Account Rules
XM and Vantage sit at opposite ends here. One needs a new account, the other moves the one you have.
XM
XM adds a partner code only when an account is created. Open a new account under your current XM profile with our partner code, then move your funds with an internal transfer.
Source: XM partner code guide, as of .
Vantage
Existing Vantage clients can change affiliate from their profile with the Transfer IB/CPA/Sales form.
- XM: XM attaches a partner code only when an account is created, so an existing account cannot change partner. You open a second account under the same profile with our code and move your funds. Source: XM partner code guide, as of . Follow our guide to move an existing XM account.
- Vantage: Vantage lets you move the same account to us through the Transfer IB/CPA/Sales form under Profile. Source: Vantage help center, as of . Use our steps to transfer your Vantage account.
With XM, your trading history stays on the old account and only lots on the new account earn our cashback. With Vantage, the account number stays the same and cashback starts once the transfer is approved.
Time the move for a quiet moment. Close trades on the account you plan to empty, move funds when no position depends on that margin. Once the new link is in place, sign up and link your XM account in your dashboard. Vantage accounts are linked by our team for now, so contact us with the account number.
Regulation and Entity for Asian Clients
XM and Vantage both place most Asian clients with entities outside the UK and EU. Read the entity name and licence number on your account agreement, then check them on the regulator's website.
| Broker | Entity | Regulator | Licence | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vantage | Vantage Markets (Pty) Ltd | Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) | 51268 | Vantage regulation page |
| XM | XM Global Limited | Financial Services Commission of Belize | 000261/27 | XM regulation page |
For XM, that entity is XM Global Limited, overseen by the Financial Services Commission of Belize. For Vantage, it is Vantage Markets (Pty) Ltd, overseen by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA).
In Japan, XM operates as XMTrading through separate entities, and our XM cashback does not cover XMTrading accounts. Source: Myforex, as of .
Vantage does not take clients from China or Singapore, among other countries. Source: Vantage help center, as of .
What does offshore mean in practice? The broker is supervised, but usually with fewer client money rules, a smaller compensation scheme or none, and a complaints process run abroad. Keep that in mind when you decide how much to deposit, and never deposit money you need for living costs.
Which One for Your Style
Our verdict for each kind of trader.
- Promotion hunters: XM, because it runs its own Unlimited Cashback promotion next to our rebate. Check the stacking line before you count on both.
- Scalpers: raw accounts with a commission per side keep each trade cheap. XM pays no rebate on trades closed within five minutes, so Vantage RAW ECN is the better fit for fast trading.
- Existing clients: Vantage clients can keep their account and move it with the transfer form. XM clients need a new account under the same profile. The existing account section has the steps for both.
- Gold traders: compare the gold rows in the cost table. Gold volume moves the result more than EUR/USD does.
- Beginners: a standard account with no commission keeps all costs in the spread, which is easier to track. Check the accounts column for each broker's standard option.
- Swing traders: holding overnight brings swap costs, and swaps on gold can be large. Ask about swap free terms before you hold gold for days.
Deciding between XM and Exness instead? Read XM vs Exness.
FAQs
Is XM or Vantage better for cashback?
XM suits traders who want XM promotions plus our rebate, once stacking is confirmed. Vantage suits RAW ECN traders and anyone moving an existing account, thanks to its transfer form. Our per lot rates for both are in the table above.
Can I switch my XM account to you?
Not the same account. XM only adds codes at signup, so open a new account under your profile with our code. Vantage accounts can be transferred with a form.
Pick the account that fits your trading, open or move it under our code, then claim your rebate.